Have been seeing Dr Rothenberg since my first GYN, my pregnancy which required an endocrinologist, to surgery for cysts, and now finally menopause...thankful to have had him to care for me every step of the way. Takes the time to listen, and truly help..thank you!

Submitted May 15, 2015

Not sure if they are any more considerate these days, but my experience at this Dr.s practice was not a memorable one. I came in a few years ago in my 40s for my second (high risk) after infertility and wasn't impressed with this practice The midwife sucked;I had to see her once on a Friday, because drs. were gone, for an ultrasound check and she couldn't find the baby's heartbeat and told me there was a problem and to come back on Monday--are you fing kidding me. Then, One of the reasons I chose the practice was because there were two doctors, so one would be available at delivery time. I told them this! and I had visits with both. Unfortunately,I delivered on my due date Easter/Passover and both decided to bail, without warning,for that holiday weekend. Baby had heart issues during the 24 labor. Neither dr. called me. An elderly doctor who I had never met delivered baby, very last minute and didn't know how to prep cord blood...I left the practice after birth.

Submitted June 22, 2014

I LOVE Dr. Rothenberg. However, his staff, not so much. The receptionist was awful. I went to the front window, and she was munching on some berries in a cereal bowl....very unprofessional. She was munching and slobbering away on her berries. And her attitude was horrible, she acted as if I was bothering her. Very sloppy and unprofessional first impression on a dr's office. If it was my first time there, I would have walked out!

Submitted June 6, 2012

Dr. Rothenberg is absolutely wonderful. I had my first appointment with him after numerous years of problems, and not getting any help from my previous gyno. He was very friendly, warm, and caring. He listened to everything I had to say and was able to give me an accurate diagnosis. Instead of rambling off how he would like to treat me(like most doctors do),we sat and talked together about a plan and treatment we would both be happy with. I highly recommend him. His staff is also fantastic. Very friendly and very helpful.

Submitted June 1, 2012

I love dr.Rothenberg. He and his staff has been nothing but wonderful. I'm pregnant with my second baby and can't imagine going to the other dr. We had some complications at the beginning of the pregnancy and I can't tell you how professional and great he and his staff have been about it. I would recommend him to everyone. Dr. Omay (his partner) is great too!!

Submitted April 18, 2012

I highly recommend Dr. Rothenberg. I lost our first child (5 months)not knowing that i had a blood disorder. Dr. Rothenberg sent me out for lots of tests/blood work and referred me to the best specialist and I am now under special medication and 21 weeks pregnant and everything is going great thanks to Dr. Rothenberg. in many other cases, other drs would have waited till I had 2 or 3 miscarriages but not him and I thank him from the bottom of my heart!

Submitted Oct. 6, 2011

I have been using Dr. Rothenberg for years. He delivered both my children and I love him. Very calm, knowledgeable and understanding to your needs whatever they might be. We couldn't get pregnant and he put us on the right path and we succeeded. I now live in Pennsylvania and make the hour long commute once a year to see him. I wouldn't go anywhere else.

Submitted Aug. 8, 2011

I was referred to Dr. Rothenberg by my past gyno and had surgery performed by him. He was extremely helpful, knowledgabel and put my mind at ease. I have since changed to him ft and left my other gyno -- if he can handle serious problems he certainly cna handle routine check ups. I love how he gets on the phone and talks to you. I was happy with his calmness and knowledge.

Submitted May 25, 2011

I really like Dr. Rothenberg, he's so nice and friendly. I usually get very nervous at a gyn exam but he puts me at ease. I never have to wait a long time to see him and his staff is wonderful and very professional. The office environment is top notch. I'm not having any more babies but if I were I would have him care for me in a heartbeat.

Submitted Nov. 19, 2010

I have been a patient of Dr. Rothenberg since six months before my birth. I'm now 19 and have been seeing him since I was 17. He has superb bedside manners and treats me like his own daughter. My mom has been very happy with the two surgical procedures he performed on her. I do recommend the Succasunna office rather than the Denville one.

Submitted Aug. 5, 2010