If it was possible to give negative stars I would. She does not return phone calls. Your prescriptions are not sent in as you are told they will be. You never get to see her only some 1st year resident working with her that cannot do anything without having it signed off by an actual Doctor. I recommend finding someone who cares and looks after their patients needs.

Submitted Dec. 1, 2023

She's a very rude and dismissive doctor. I had to find a new one.

Submitted Jan. 5, 2023

Dr Holinaty is the best doctor I have ever met. She is extremely knowledgeable and is always willing to take the time to listen to all of my concerns. So thankful to have found such an amazing doctor!

Submitted Nov. 12, 2021

Dr Holinaty is a great doctor. She is very knowledgeable and I trust her 100%. I recommend Dr Holinaty.

Submitted Nov. 12, 2021

One of the smartest people I have ever had the pleasure to meet and one of the few physicians that takes time to listen to patients and respond to their concerns. Genuinely cares about all the people of Saskatoon and Saskatchewan, even those too ignorant to respect professional and informed opinions.

Submitted Nov. 12, 2021

Best doctor in town! Friendly, caring and knowledgeable.

Submitted Nov. 12, 2021

More worried about pandemic politics than her patients care nowadays. Arrogant and dismissive when I asked questions. Will not be returning.

Submitted Oct. 28, 2021

I was a patient of Dr. Holinaty's for several years. She started out good, then over time developed a "god complex" and major superiority issues (seemed to coincide with her becoming a professor). Here's an example. I got an IUD put in and had trouble (constant bleeding). When I booked a follow-up, I was told I had to "tough it up" and was refused an ultrasound or any checks on the positioning of the IUD. After that appt, Hollinaty transferred me to another Dr. without even telling me. Fast forward a few years, I find out the IUD was put in wrong, would have been found by an ultrasound when I asked, but only got discovered when it finally moved more and nearly punctured my uterus. Be careful with Dr. Holinaty, she's great at the superficial sugarcoating, but there's not much beneath the surface.

Submitted Aug. 9, 2021

Dr. Holinaty is a good doctor but for the past few years I haven’t been able to see her when I book an appointment, 2-3 times a year for myself or my children. Every visit I’ve seen an intern. They’re mostly good, but always someone new. I’d look for a new doctor if I felt I could find anything better, just to have reliability. She’s open to us working with multiple professionals on our health and their feedback. Maybe she’s trying to push our family out of our care by never seeing us? Starting to wonder.

Submitted June 23, 2021

Absolutely LOVE Dr. Holinaty. Have always had major anxiety when it comes to the doctor but I’m now very comfortable. As a married queer woman with a toddler, my wife and I have never felt uncomfortable when it comes to discussing sexuality, pregnancy, fertility etc. My only “complaint” is that she is quite busy, however-I have never had a bad experience with a single doctor I’ve seen at the clinic so I’m generally happy to see anyone available. Very, very happy to be a patient at West Winds.

Submitted Oct. 13, 2020