Dr. Chalnick explains all procedures in clear and concise language. He doesn't rush through your visits with him. You know he generally care for the well being of all his patients. I feel comfortable with him performing surgery on me.

Submitted Oct. 18, 2022

Doctor is excellent. What more can be said!!! HE has an above board reputation in Monmouth County . He has a 0% infection rate. His surgical expertise is far beyond any doctor in NJ.

Submitted Jan. 4, 2019

He is terrible. Before you decide to go with hi, ask him about his performance in general. I believe he invented the word revision, revision means let's do it again--the first one did not work.

Submitted Nov. 21, 2017

Dr. Chalice has replaced both a knee and hip for me. I had surgery September 15, 2016. He is the best total replacement surgeon in the area! I would not go to any other surgeon. I trust everything he says, has good judgement and most importantly is the best at this type of surgery. The office staff is also great and very on top of everything for their patients. I highly recommend Dr. Chalnick!

Submitted Oct. 6, 2016

I had both of my hips replaced by Dr Chalnick. Recovery was quick and uneventful. I have no regrets and feel better than I have in years. His surgical assistant is Debbie and she is wonderful. She freely gives out her direct number and is always available for questions. The remainder of his office staff from the front desk to x-ray to exam room are professional and foremost kind.

Submitted Aug. 22, 2016

I had my left hip done May 14th...I am walking almost perfectly. No cane or walker. It's been 5 weeks. Felling great. He is a very well respected Doctor at Monmouth Medical. He is very strick , but it pays off in the end. I would definitely recommend him.

Submitted June 22, 2015

Dr. Chalice preformed a total left knee replacement on me 6 years ago. He was thorough, informative, & took every aspect of my health & well being into consideration. My right knee is now on its way out. I wouldn't consider going to another surgeon.

Submitted Sept. 30, 2014

I am getting surprised that most of the comments seem to be about time and office personal. Whatv about the doctor. He is a great surgeon. His very honest, straight forward and gives you options. I like this guy. I am doing it in the Fall.

Submitted Aug. 9, 2013

I have a partially torn ACL. Dr Chalnick recommended physical therapy. After a few months of physical therapy and not much progress, I requested to that he follow through with arthroscopic surgery with a cadaver ACL. He tried to convince me to have tendons taken from my leg to do the repair because there was a possibility of contracting HIV/AIDS. I told him there was a better chance of my body rejecting the cadaver. After we had the surgery scheduled, while I was on the table, WHILE HE HAD STARTED THE SURGERY AND I WAS CUT OPEN, he decided not to follow through with the surgery and told me to go back to physical therapy to strengthen my knee. He also said there was a mass behind my knee that he didn't look at because he didn't have my permission. My mom was in the waiting room and had permission to make decisions. Even though I didn't get the surgery completed I was still on the hook for paying what my insurance didn't cover. I can't recommend this "doctor" at all.

Submitted Jan. 11, 2013

Dr David Chalnick, did a left knee replacement on 2/24/2011, I am walking with a caine very little pain or swelling. I had my right knee done on 3/9/2010 by a famous Dr at NYHSS and I am still having problems with them right knee, my advise is stay local and go to DR chalnick

Submitted March 12, 2011