Dr. William Murtagh


Naples, Florida Map External Link
Specialty:Cosmetic / Plastic Surgeon
Website: naplesplasticsurgeo... External Link
Practice: William O. Murtagh, M.D.
Med. School:
Grad. Year: 1952

Answers Email: Unknown
Online Appt. Scheduling: Unknown
Accepting New Patients:Y

Profile updated 28/08/13    Submit profile update    Subscribe to profile updates

Rating: 3.6 out of 5 (5 is best), based on 10 reviews. Dr. William Murtagh has a good overall rating on RateMDs.com. smile

New! - Questions and answers about this doctor

Cosmetic / Plastic Surgeon-related: plastic surgery, cosmetic surgery, breast enhancement, breast reduction, liposuction, chin implant, rhinoplasty, nose job, tummy tuck, botox, face lift, boob job, butt lift
The following ratings and comments have not been substantiated by RateMDs.com.
Date Staff Punctual Helpful Knowledge Review Comments
RID: 1654417
06/12/11 2 5 1 1 Here I am roughly 3 years post lipo - my legs are deformed - nothing I can do but except that this Dr was more that rough with procedure. Today found out he has closed shop. Lets hope he put away the knives. So sad what the effects have done to me and to hear of so many affected by him. In my case you get what you pay for!  Respond
18/04/11 SYSTEM: 2 positive duplicate or disallowed ratings automatically removed 
18/04/11 SYSTEM: 2 negative duplicate or disallowed ratings automatically removed 
RID: 1211138
19/07/10 5 5 5 5 I am simply amazed at the negative comments I have read on this site about Dr. Murtagh, which apparently all come from the same one unhappy customer. It leads me to think that the saying "one cannot make a silk purse from a sow's ear" might possibly apply to the negative commentor. My wife and I have both undergone major liposuction and brow lift operations with him and we could not be happier with our experience. His ability as a surgeon was superb and he and his staff were the epitome of professionalism. He was both knowlegable and kind and very caring about our needs, before, during, and after our surgeries. He made sure that we were comfortable and pain-free during and after our surgeries. He personally called us at our home after both surgeries for a post-operative check and even sent his P. A. by our home to check on us after our liposuction procedures. My wife and I both give Dr. Murtagh the highest rating and recommendation possible. Our recommendation is honest and unsolicited  Respond
16/06/10 SYSTEM: 2 positive duplicate or disallowed ratings automatically removed 
RID: 1160878
01/05/10 5 5 5 5 I can't say enough good things about Dr. Murtagh. I had breast surgery and am delighted. He has become more than my doctor, but a friend as well. He's a great surgeon. He's also a great person.  Respond
RID: 1155186
22/04/10 5 5 5 5 Dr Murtagh has done several procedures on me and I think he is excellent. He is the kindest person, cares about you as a patient and does it utmost to make you happy. I would recommenmd him to all my friends. He treats you as a person and cares about you personally. Extremely professional office. Very happy!!!  Respond
RID: 1154001
21/04/10 5 5 5 5 I had eyelid and underneath my eyes done. I am very pleased with the resuts.Everyone in the office was professional, courteous and comforting. I would recommend Dr. Murtagh to all my friends. Joan, Estero.  Respond
RID: 1153973
21/04/10 5 5 5 5 You know, this kind of web review is most unfair. Let's be honest, people come to a plastic surgeon, because they are unhappy with themselves to begin with. Why would they be happy with others? There is no way to know the truth behind negative claims. Maybe it was an ugly patient, that remained ugly? Maybe it was someone that didn't want to pay? Point is, that the anonymous nature of online rating makes it so easy to dump on anyone. Would these unhappy people say the same things if they had to put their real names and addresses? No Way! The nature of these procedures is open to 1000 variables and none can be guaranteed. My experience was nothing but GREAT! Dr. Murtagh took the time, was fair in price, was professional and did the best job anyone could have done considering my specific problem, which was severe! My outcome was awesome and I'd recommend him to anyone! Dave --from Naples. I invite anyone that wrote negative things to put their full name here!  See Responses
20/12/09 SYSTEM: 2 positive duplicate or disallowed ratings automatically removed 
RID: 1051179
06/12/09 1 3 1 1 "4/9/08 Dr's request to reduce required drug screens to once per month was granted" that is from the medical board of ohio. It haunts me that this man is just allowed to hurt people with no apology or acknowledgement. Brief outline: went for implants-was told needed a lift-Dr said lift would be free with the implants-woke up with no implants-cut too much skin-skin opened after went home-raw hamburger and bleeding for days-open wounds both breasts-.-scarred badly-inch wide jagged scars-stupidly had implants put in when healed-asked to fix scarring- said "we'll see--areolas stretched like small saucers--it was a nightmare. His manner was unsympathetic and cold. Finally went to another ps feeling so deformed I didn't think he could fix it. If you want ps, go see someone else. My experience was a nightmare.  See Responses
RID: 954578
04/08/09 5 5 5 5 I cannot believe the comments I have read on this site about Dr. Murtagh. My experience with him as a surgeon was superb and 110% professional. He was kind and very compassionate, and his plastic surgery was a work of art. He changed my life and I will forever be grateful to him for the work he did for me. He made sure I was pain-free throughout and after my surgery. I could only give Dr. Murtagh the highest rating and recommendation possible. He was extremely polite at all times. He is truly a gifted surgeon and the outcome of my surgery was so much better than I ever anticipated.  See Responses
RID: 784338
07/02/09 2 2 1 1   See Responses
RID: 771332
23/01/09 1 5 2 4   Respond
* - Rating left by a registered user