Rate Dr. David Martin
Dr. David Martin's Ratings
I had knee surgery with Dr. Martin in January of 2013. He pinned a large piece of cartilage back on to the end of my femur. I was only 21 at the time and if he wasn't able to do it he said I would have needed a half knee replacement. Luckily he was able to put it back on BUT after the surgery he gave me no information. I was told it worked but he never indicated I needed physiotherapy or to do any exercises. I didn't even know if I should take my splint off to do any. It's a year and a half later and I still feel pain in my knee.
Submitted Aug. 24, 2014 | flag
A great surgeon; however he had a massive temper tantrum just before I was head in the OR for my hip replacement and muscle reconstruction. His staff loaded me up with morphine before my surgery, then they cut me off when I'm in real pain after the surgery. Talk about backwards.
Submitted Aug. 23, 2014 | flag
Dr. Martin did a great job on my knee replacement. He is very busy but very professional. I would recommend him to anyone considering knee replacement surgery. I had read his ratings. His receptionist was also very professional. As a patient I don't want a new best friend for a Doctor or his receptionist. I want competent people and that is who you have with Dr.Martin and his Staff. If you want a new best friend - go buy a dog! If you want the best Doctor for knee replacement - Dr. Martin and his team are who you really want. Because he is busy, go prepared - write down your questions, he will answer them all for you. Thank you!
Submitted June 11, 2014 | flag
My husband had a humeral break and after waiting for a day and a half "on call" for surgery we finally got a chance to see Dr. Martin. He was in the room for about 1 minute and flat out said "we're going to cut you from here to here and put in a plate." When I asked how big the incision/plate is he just made a hand gesture which looked about 9 inches long. He gave very little information in terms of recovery times. He just came across as a doctor wanting to do surgery because it serves him best rather than take into consideration my husbands concerns/situation. The next day we met with another surgeon who said in NO way would he ever operate as the risks were too high and the benefits were minimal. Thankfully, we got the doctor we did. I later received feedback from 2 other doctors after showing them my husbands' fracture and they agreed surgery was definitely not necessary.
Submitted Jan. 29, 2014 | flag
he went on vacation before i awoke and could ask any questions. After weeks of calling ...the office was closed. I finally got them to answer questions about my surgery and how it went. Then after a month and a half , they finally got me into physio theraphy. Very disapointed
Submitted Jan. 27, 2014 | flag
I had a unstable shoulder that popped out, went to see Dr.Martin. I was told a wait of 12-18mnths I was not happy about the wait time cause I was in so much pain. I had called bad and asked to be put on the waiting list they called me 3mnth later to book the surgery, between the time waiting I went to see another surgeon. who was very rude and yelled at me. anyways i book surgery with martin and booked an appointment with him before surgery to go over everything. I had told him about the surgeon and Dr. Martin sent about 45min to an Hour just talking about the surgery and everything. It made me feel so much better as i was very confused after seeing the other dr. The surgery went great! i couldn't be happier best thing i could of done!!! Only thing make sure you do research about the surgery or whats wrong with you. It will help with talking to him. The rep seems very cold but very helpful too!
Submitted Jan. 21, 2014 | flag
Dr. Martin did bilateral knee replacements for me last November (10 months ago)and I can't say enough about how great my new knees are. I'm only 57 and had the knees of an 80 year old. My one leg was bowed and quite crooked. Now I have straight knees and no pain. I was back to yoga and swimming in only 8 weeks with a 130 range of motion!!!! Dr. Martin did my mother's knees (at the same time) when she was 72. She is now almost 80 and is back to walking and enjoying life. I cannot say enough about Dr. Martin and his surgery. I have recommended many people to him. He was my 3rd opinion.
Submitted Oct. 1, 2013 | flag
3 days ago my brother had a bicycle accident. He was in severe pain, his left shoulder looked dislocated as bones were sticking out and looked asymmetric. Dr Martin said clavicle slightly dislocated, nothing can be done. I wasn't satisfied, took my brother to Welland general, dr Jamal saw him and immediately had him under general anesthesia and fixed his shoulder. As soon as my brother awoke, his shoulder was 90% better. Dr Jamal said the shoulder would have never healed properly. My msg is: don't let dr Martin operate on you (my friend's Ankle was operated on by Dr Martin, three years later, still can't walk and still on OxyContin!) if you need a surgery run to Welland or hamilton. A Dr that thinks he is God's gift to ppl, shouldn't be in medical care. Please read other reviews, good reviews are probably posted by either lucky patients or staff members.
Submitted June 23, 2013 | flag
I have nothing but great things to say about Dr. D Martin.As a former member of a national sports team, i am still very active at 74.Dr. Martin replaced my right hip in March 2011, fantastic job.My neighbour had both hips replaced last year, on my recommendation to Dr Martin, great job again.We both love the results and are able to enjoy the gym thanks to Dr. Martin's excellent work.We found him to be very professional, right to the point,no flowery talks. Very pleasant man with very good bedside manners. We both would go to him again in a heart beat. Thanks Dr. Martin!!!
Submitted Feb. 8, 2013 | flag
I agree with the last poster. Stay away!!! And ask for a copy of your patient records. This surgeon says terrible things about his patients in them, so stay informed. I think all the positive reviews on this page have been written by his staff. None of the positive reviews square with the things I heard about him at the hospital.
Submitted Feb. 24, 2012 | flag
Find a Doctor by Specialty
Top Orthopedic Surgeons
#1 of 27
#2 of 27
#3 of 27
#4 of 27
#5 of 27