Dr. Macaulay is the most knowledgeable surgeon who truly cares. I received excellent results after my hip surgery. From day one, Dr. Macaulay provided me with total confidence the surgical procedure will be a success.

Submitted March 28, 2023

You can't find a better surgeon. He replaced both hips & right knee. They went perfectly

Submitted Feb. 17, 2023

Dr McCauley is Excellent and I will absolutely recommend him and the entire team I felt safe and confident informative 100 percent

Submitted Oct. 27, 2021

Dr. Macaulay is the most knowledgeable surgeon who truly cares for his patients. NYU offices and staff are the best.

Submitted April 22, 2018

Best joint surgeon in the world. His bedside manner and knowledge of conservative treatments are outstanding. His office at NYU and staff are amazing. Highest rec!

Submitted Dec. 11, 2017

Best orthopaedic surgeon in the world! Just saw Dr. M post-operatively at his new NYU offices and it has been an incredible experience. Surgery and post operative care spot on. I have my life back and can mobilize again. Ten stars to Dr. M!!!

Submitted March 23, 2017

He was dismissive. Since he had no idea.what to do, he could not wait to.get rid of me. I waited for a long time in a hot stuffy.so called waiting room. He never introduced.himself and was rude. His staff is sloppy and.not.helpful. This traumatic experience may have turned me off to the entire medical profession.

Submitted July 15, 2016

I had total knee replacement surgery with Dr Macaulay two and a half weeks ago and am fully ambulatory without even a cane. I haven't even started PT yet. My first replacement was 5 years ago and I thought I did pretty good then. I couldn't be happier. I highly recommend Dr. Macaulay and the staff at the Joint Replacement Center at NYP-Lawrence Hospital in Bronxville. The care by the nursing and PT staff was exceptional.

Submitted Feb. 21, 2016

After I visited ER due to a knee pain on my left leg, I saw Dr Macaulay. At first he seemed nice and ordered an MRI. However, when results showed a cycts on bone with a minor bone damage, he send me home with antiinflamator and told me to visit him 2 years later! There was no treatment, no further follow up or check up and worse, when I complained him that I have a similar pain on right knee as well, he told me "he is pretty sure the same thing is going on on my right knee, so no need to check it"! On top of all, I have a family history of bad knees ! I am still shocked that I was send home with no further care!

Submitted April 2, 2009

Excellent.

Submitted Feb. 25, 2009